Technical and economic comparison of performance between farmer and government managed irrigation schemes in Tanzania: a case study of Kapunga irrigation project
Loading...
Date
1996
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Sokoine University of Agriculture
Abstract
This study compares the performance of government-managed irrigation schemes (GMIS) to farmer-managed irrigation schemes (FMIS) at Kapunga rice irrigation project in Mbeya region in Tanzania. The specific objectives were to evaluate: (i) organisational structure of the two systems; (ii) water management aspects of the two systems; productivity and Appropriate (iii) economic performance of the two systems. Indicators been have used to quantify performance of the two types of management of irrigation. Results of the study show that the farmer-managed scheme, performed better than the government-managed scheme in attaining scheme irrigation efficiency, productivity,economic, and productivity, irrigation scheme financial in profitability. Applicable indicators for the farmer-managed irrigation schemes are quantified as shown below. Those of the government-managed scheme are indicated in brackets. efficiency was 61% (29%) ;Its overall irrigation average productivity was 3.2 ton/ha (2.2 ton/ha); economic profitability: internal rate of return was 3.2% (5%), benefit/cost ratio 0.6 (0.14); while its financial profitability: internal rate of return was 3.9% (5.1%), benefit/cost ratio 0.6 (0.13). The organisation of both the government and farmer-managed irrigation schemes were appropriate, however, both schemes were weak in irrigation management as the essential operation and maintenance activities were not carried out effectively. Schemes Both the government and the farmer-managed had canal maintenance problem. There was corresponding big error in water adequacy of 86% and 98% respectively arising from improper water control at the secondary canals offtake.Paddy nurseries in the government-managed scheme had undesirable water stress. However, both schemes were able to distribute water equitably, reliably, as well as maintaining a correct field water depth from tillering to flowering and grain formation stages.
Description
Dissertation
Keywords
Irrigation Schemes, Soil Moisture, Government-managed irrigation schemes, Tanzania